Prevent Ring Around The Collar For Good

July 24, 2011 | By | 24 Replies More

A reader stopped by yesterday and posted a comment here and asked about whether or not a mock neck undershirt would help prevent ring around the collar.

While a higher necked undershirt/t-shirt would likely reduce the amount of oils, dirt, and dead skin that would get in the inside collar of your favorite shirts, not all of us are willing to trade in our favorite undershirts.

Coincidentally, I’ve been thinking about this very issue recently because even though I wear an undershirt much of the time which allows me to wear a shirt more than once between washings/dry cleanings, the one thing I have yet to avoid is the dreaded ring around the collar. I get it pretty much every time I wear a collared shirt.

So, there’s two ways to think about this problem; 1) Cleaning ring around the collar, or 2) Preventing ring around the collar.

There’s about a gazillion sites out there that provide ideas on how to clean ring around the collar, but I was more curious about how to PREVENT it.

Funny enough, I had come up with some ideas on how I would approach solving the problem my, and then I got curious on whether or not anyone else had invented a similar solution. So I hit the keyboard, started googling away, and this is what I found.

Solutions to Prevent Ring Around the Collar:

  1. White Collar Grime: collar & hat protectors – From the company that brought you Garment Guards, these are 100% super-soft cotton strips with adhesive backing. Cut to size and place the disposable cotton strip on the inside of your collar. Throw away after use. Price: $9.95 for a 10′ roll (1.25″ wide).
  2. KOllar Guards – Same principle, but KOllar Guards are made from super-soft/smooth rayon and are 100% bio-degradable. Price: $19.95 for 24 strips.
  3. InCollar – offered by Population 3. Not sure what material the strip is made from, but InCollar uses a skin safe hypoallergenic adhesive, and come in different lengths based on your collar size. Price: $8.99 for a pack of 15.
  4. Clean Collar – found this one on Etsy. Price: $9.95 for a pack of 10 (each strip is 12″ long)
  5. White Athletic tape – compliments from the very intelligent folks over at the forums of AskAndyAboutClothes.com. Another version of this is the white wide fabric medical tape you can get at your local drugstore.
  6. If you dig through a bunch of forums including AskAndyAboutClothes.com and the ArtofManliness, some suggest that cleaning/scrubbing your neck, or applying a talc powder to the back part of your neck that comes in contact with the collar of your shirt are also ways to minimizing ring around the collar.

I’m definitely going to try out one or more of these products and see how well they work and I’ll report back. I think the pricing on these items might be a little on the high side though. Paying $0.60 – $1 per use seems a little steep to me, although I guess you could argue that a strip *could* be used more than once.

To me, it appears that there’s one common design flaw theme that all of the above products have – but I don’t want to let the cat out of the bag. Who knows, maybe I’ll work on a little side project and see if I can come up with an alternate solution to address it!

If you’ve tried one of the above products, let me know what you think of them. Also, if you know of any other ways to prevent ring around the collar, please tell me about it in the comments section below.

Tags: , , , , , , , , , ,

Category: Ask Tug

About the Author ()

Tug is the world's undershirt expert. Looking for undershirt or men's shapewear information? You'll find it here on my site - guaranteed! You can also find me on

Comments (24)

Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed

  1. james says:

    So guys you all have very interesting views about the different options on protecting the shirt collar. What about the wrist band and the under arm area.

    • Tug says:

      heya james,

      i don’t wear long sleeve shirts very often, so i can’t offer any good preventative suggestions. though, for cleaning grease/dirt build up i’d recommend trying something like oxi-clean or a mixture of dish-soap and hydrogen peroxide. i tried the latter mixture on some stained underarms and a pretty dirty shirt collar. while it didn’t clean the underarm stains, it did do a good job of cleaning my neck collar.

      for underarm (pit) stain removal, the best solutions include deo-go, raise, and oxi-clean.

      i think the only ways to prevent underarm stains would be to:
      1. stop using antiperspirant and switch to deodorant — though you would not get any underarm sweat prevention
      2. making sure your antiperspirant is completely dry before putting on your clothes (aka, use a hair dryer on cool setting to dry the antiperspirant)
      3. switch to a 7-day antiperspirant like sweatblock or kleinerts dry body wipes
      4. wear underarm pads or liners (pretty inconvenient if you ask me)

      hope this info helps!

  2. Su says:

    Hi! Any advances on this? I was thinking anout how I could make some washable collar guards for my husband, and after searching online, was amazed that I couldn’t find any suggestions at all. I was wondering about making something that would fit around the neck rather something that would need to be attached to the collar. Any more ideas anyone?

    • Tug says:

      heya su! thanks for stopping by my site and joining in on the conversation (:

      not to discourage, but i think the potential drawback of designing something that fit around the neck is that it would only be able to be used when wearing a tie (collar closed, top button fastened). i don’t know how it is where you live, but there’s a lot of business casual where i live — and most guys don’t wear ties.

      the stick on solutions presented here are made from fabric and attach to the collar, so the shirt can be worn open or closed.

      that said, a stretchy piece of real thin fabric, about 1″ wide, that could be fastened around the neck with a simple clasp, velcro or something similar might do the trick as well. the question is how would guys feel wearing something around their neck, and how would it look if the shirt collar didn’t ride close to the neck, and you could see the band?

      the good part of your idea is that you never have to worry about sticking or unsticking it from a shirt. you can use it a bunch of times and then throw it in the wash for cleaning. plus, it would be just like putting on a tie — just another accessory i’d put on in the morning. from a practicality point of view, that great, but from a business pov, i’m not sure.

      see, if i can buy one and use it bunch, and it takes a while to wear out, i don’t have to re-order very much. maybe once ever couple of years? that may or may not be a good business proposition — though you never know if you sell a million of them!

      idk — whadaya think?? let’s brainstorm!

      • Su says:

        Hmm, true, seems something attached around the neck would be too visible, that’s true. Oh well. And Scotch Guard is made of chemicals, which I don’t think would be very healthy long term, used all day every day.

        • Su says:

          I meant to add that the first idea would be too visible, even with the button done up and tie on! I think it might show, and even just slightly showing, it would probably look weird, right? Oh well.

  3. 1rktect says:

    Two words…Scotch guard! Saved tons of cash on white shirts! Stains wash right out! Works great on my ties as well!

    • great idea! will definitely keep that in mind — so much easier and convenient than using collar guards (:

    • Mr. Nimieri says:

      If you don’t mind my asking, should Scotch Guard be applied to the collar prior to wearing for the 1st time?

      • 1rktect says:

        I spray them as soon as I pull them out of the package…let it dry, then take them to the cleaners…if you spray after, you risk locking in whatever is already there from the first wear. But you can certainly try it.

  4. B says:

    What would be ideal for me is a mock neck T-shirt that has a mock neck in the back, but then tapers down to a normal neck in the front of the T-shirt. My ring around the collar is always in the back, and this would make it less noticeable that you’re wearing a mock neck. Have you ever heard of such a product?

    • hey b! thanks for stopping by my site and posting your question!

      i think you’re on to a great idea there — but sadly i have not seen any undershirt that had such a feature or collar.

      a slight variation of that idea, that i think could be implemented rather easily, would be to design a piece of fabric with some edge reinforcement, that could be flipped up or down as needed, and have that sewn/constructed into the back side of the shirt on the inside of the collar.

      this way you could wear it down when you wear non-collared shirts and up when you wear collared shirts.

      what do you think of that idea?

  5. John Doe says:

    I fly for an airline and wearing my white button up pilot shirt daily I deal with this all the time. One day, I took a few tissues in the hotel room and folded them in a way that they wouldn’t stick up above the collar, but placed between my neck and the collar. For sure reduces the collar ring, some days it’s not noticeable. I’m trying to find a soft cotton liner that’s removable and washable. The shirts get nasty after working 14 hours a day, so I’m sometimes left with carrying around a scrub brush, sometimes forced to wash it in the sink.

    • heya john d! thanks for stopping by my site. what did you think of the solutions i found which are listed on this page?

      i’ve tried the first two collar guard product so far, and they definitely do what they are designed for — preventing ring around the collar (on your actual shirt).

      let me know what you decide to try and what you think of it!

  6. Eugene Hennie says:

    Check out http://thecguard.com. They sell the ring around the collar strips but also have a great blog with some cool articles. So it’s kinda like a one stop shop

  7. Mark says:

    Hey Undershirt Guy, have you ever tried My Clean Shirt to remove ring around the collar stains? It works really good I have even had success removing “Set” stains. I’m talking about shirts that had been washed and dried several times.

    If its something you want to try; let me know and I will send you a free sample. We would appreciate you posting your results on your site….yea, it really works.
    If your interested email me at opusunlimited@gmail.com

    Here’s the website: http://www.mycleanshirt.com

    Thanks,
    Mark

  8. Imdgc says:

    Any luck on any of these products or something else?

    • b says:

      Imdgc –

      It has been over six months and I have yet to get ring around the collar after switching to the mock neck tee from Jockey (link at beginning of this blog)

      I am required to wear a white button-up and tie for work daily.

      I utilize 3 button-up shirts ($189.99 ea.) and get two wears each before laundering. I own ten Jockey mock tees ($7.00 ea.) and wear them exclusively as my undershirt.

      Before the switch, these button-ups would be trash given the same scenario and length of time.

      I am 5’10” 180lbs. and currently wear XL in Jockey tee. Next purchase I will go up one size for added tucking length.

      The neck and shirt as a whole has remained just as good as new. I do have to roll the front just a little to keep from showing over top button but is so comfortable it isn’t noticed while wearing tee.

      I would try it …. what’s $7 bucks lost if you hate it … a latte?

      b

    • hey lmdgc & b! thanks for stopping by, posting your comments and sharing your feedback.

      i’ve personally tried white collar grime and kollar guards and have to say that they unequivocally work to prevent ring around the collar. they are both easy to put on, and generally unnoticeable. with the use of an undershirt, i can get easily 2-3 wears out of my shirts, and not get any ring around the collar or any body oils, residue, or underarm sweat on my outer shirts.

      i will say though, that i think the pricing is a little off. paying $10 – $20 per month, on average, just to prevent ring around the collar feels a bit too much for me to incorporate into my every day life. for me to do that, it would have to be priced more like antiperspirant, razors, hairspray, etc. i can spend around $5 for my antiperspirant, and it’ll easily last a couple of months. same goes for razors and hairspray (although my hair isn’t all that long).

      just some food for thought. the products work for sure though and i was very pleased with their performance.

  9. b says:

    Tug –

    While reading the thorough review you gave Jockey’s Mock Neck T-Shirt yesterday, I knew I had come to the right place for advice.

    My friend — You’ve taken this to another level!

    Your time and effort is GREATLY appreciated by myself and most likely by gentlemen for a long time to come should you solve this riddle.

    Nevertheless, I am glad to have ‘The Undershirt Guy’ on my side regarding the matter.

    b

Leave a Reply


Notify me of follow-up comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.